...

My Dad Had Prostate Cancer. Nobody Asked Me About It.

Nobody told me that prostate and breast cancer can run in the same family. I worked it out four years after my own diagnosis.

The line I’d rewrite

On the first page of my book, Flat Please, Hold the Shame, I wrote that I was fit and healthy and had no family history of breast cancer.

I believed it. Somewhere along the way, I’d been told that breast cancer risk came down through your mother’s side. There was no breast cancer on my mother’s side. No cancer at all. So, no family history. Case closed.

It never occurred to me to look at my father’s side, or that prostate cancer and breast cancer might be connected.

That is where I got it wrong. The genes linked to breast cancer can be passed down by either parent, to sons as well as daughters.

But throughout the course of my diagnosis and treatment, even when I directly asked my oncologist about my daughter, no one ever asked me about my paternal family history.

My father’s side of the family

You see, my dad had prostate cancer. So did his father, my grandfather.

Dad was one of five kids. He and three of his siblings all died of cancer. Dad was full of cancer when he died, so we aren’t sure if prostate was the primary. My uncle died of liver cancer. My aunts died of brain cancer and breast cancer.

Now it’s my generation’s turn. I have learned that three of my first cousins have been diagnosed with cancer that I know of. Two cousins were diagnosed with breast cancer, and one with prostate cancer. One of them has had genetic testing. And then there’s me, diagnosed with breast cancer in 2022. I was never offered genetic testing.

I’m no expert, but it looks to me that there is a pattern of prostate and breast cancer on my dad’s side of the family. It took me four years, and an insightful conversation with a top urologist at a world-leading cancer hospital, and some digging into that family history to start to connect the dots.

In my parents’ generation, cancer was often something people kept to themselves. A grandfather’s prostate cancer or an uncle’s diagnosis could come and go without anyone connecting it to the women in the family. Funny, not fun fact: my mum, WHO WAS A NURSE, explained away the cancer incidence on my dad’s side by saying they ate too much fish as kids. I mean, it seemed like a perfectly reasonable explanation to me….until I was the one diagnosed.

What the research says about prostate and breast cancer

I’m not a researcher, and this isn’t medical advice. But here is what I have learned about the potential connection between prostate and breast cancer.

The link between prostate cancer and breast cancer has been studied for years. In a large study of more than 78,000 women, those whose father, brother or son had prostate cancer had a modestly higher risk of breast cancer, about 14%. When a family had both prostate and breast cancer, the increase was 78%. The study’s lead author said doctors need to ask about every cancer in the family, including cancers in the opposite sex. The researchers were honest about the limits. Fred Hutch’s Dr. Garnet Anderson called the associations modest, and said they could come from shared genes or from the shared environment families live in. The study wasn’t designed to tell the two apart. That’s an important consideration. A pattern in your family is a question, not a verdict.

Some of the same genes are involved. You’ve probably heard of the BRCA1 and BRCA2 genes. They are linked to breast, ovarian, pancreatic and prostate cancer, and to melanoma. CHEK2 and ATM genes carry risk across several cancers too, including breast and prostate.

The science is still moving. HOXB13 is a well-known prostate cancer gene. A 2026 study in the Journal of Human Genetics found new variants of it in breast cancer patients. The researchers are careful to call it a possible link that needs more work, so I will avoid framing this as a conclusion.

Most cancers aren’t inherited. Some are. Ontario Health says about 1 in 10 cancers are linked to a gene change passed down from a parent. Not cancer itself, but a higher chance of it. Your doctor helps decide whether a genetic assessment makes sense, and the province keeps a directory of genetics clinics.

None of this says my kids will get cancer. A family pattern isn’t a prediction. But it sure as heck is a good reason to ask, and that is exactly what I did at my last oncology appointment. Because it keeps nagging at me that despite all the scientific rationale I just highlighted, my dad’s side of the family seems to be a hornet’s nest of cancer, and to me, science aside, it seems far too coincidental to not take a closer look.

Genetics by the numbers

We hear about relative risk in the world of cancer. If the average woman’s lifetime risk of breast cancer is roughly 1 in 8, a modest relative increase nudges that up. It doesn’t turn it into a coin flip. A 14% increase in risk of developing cancer, is not a 14% chance you will develop cancer. Family history on its own tends to move risk by degrees, not leaps.

Genetics do have an impact on that risk. The 2024 review of DNA repair genes puts the risk of breast cancer by age 80 at about 69% for women who carry a harmful BRCA2 change, and 72% for BRCA1. This is why women who are found to be BRCA carriers will often opt for a preventative mastectomy and oopherectomy. For those carriers the risk of developing cancer is very high. For the ATM gene, it’s about a 27% chance that a carrier of that gene will develop cancer. Some CHEK2 changes more than double the risk of developing cancer for individuals who are carriers. Those same genes raise the chances of prostate, pancreatic and other cancers in the people who carry them, men included.

That gap is the whole reason testing matters in families with prostate and breast cancer. A family pattern is something to observe, and information about your family history gives you a good reason to ask if you are eligible for genetic testing. A genetic test will then tell you whether there’s an inherited change that is creating that pattern.

What a genetic test can and can’t tell you

Some folks assume a genetic test gives you a yes or a no answer. The reality is a bit messier than that. There are roughly three kinds of answers that come from a genetic test.

A harmful change is found. The lab finds a variant known to raise cancer risk. It’s the clearest result, and it’s the one that will allow relatives be tested for that exact change.

Nothing is found. What this means depends on what came before. If a relative carries a known change and you don’t, that’s genuinely reassuring news about that change. If nobody in the family has been tested, a negative result is less certain. It can mean there’s nothing there, or that the risk comes from a gene the test didn’t cover, or that science hasn’t found yet. Your family history still counts.

A variant of uncertain significance. The lab finds a change but can’t yet say whether it matters. These are common, and many turn out to be harmless once more is known. The HOXB13 study is a good example. Every new variant it described sat in this uncertain category, which is exactly why the researchers were careful. An uncertain result usually isn’t something to act on alone, and labs update their classifications as evidence builds.

A genetic counsellor’s job is to walk you through those findings what it means for you and your family. It’s a conversation, not a lab printout.

Genetic testing, and why this is about my kids

I’ve made my peace with my own diagnosis. What keeps me up is what I might have handed down.

Genetic testing usually starts with someone who has had cancer. In my family, that used to be Dad. He’s gone, so now it’s me. If a change turns up in my genetic profile, my son and my daughter would each have a 50% chance of carrying it. That would mean something for both of them. Prostate cancer is part of this story, and men get breast cancer too. If nothing turns up, that’s information as well, just a different kind.

For my son, the stakes look different, but they’re real. BRCA2 in particular is linked to prostate cancer and to male breast cancer. The best-known HOXB13 variant, found mostly in men of European descent, raised prostate cancer risk more than 20-fold in one large study, though other studies found smaller increases. Men in families with prostate and breast cancer are often the last to hear any of this, because the conversation has always been framed as a women’s issue.

My kids are adults. Whether they want to know is their decision, not mine. Some people want every piece of information they can get. Some would rather not carry it. My job is to find out what there is to know, and hand it to them when they’re ready.

My cousin’s result from genetic testing is the first piece. If they carry a known variant, I will share that information with my care team, and I can be tested for that specific change as well. If they don’t turn out to be a genetic carrier, it doesn’t rule me out. A genetic counsellor gets to make that call, not me, and not Dr. Google.

Testing isn’t only about the next generation. For someone who has already had breast cancer, a result can also shape follow-up care, including which other cancers are worth watching for. That’s a conversation for my oncologist. It’s also one more reason not to treat my own diagnosis as the end of the story.

My dad can’t be tested. I can.

The insurance question

One of the first worries people raise about genetic testing is insurance. Will a result make it harder for my kids to get life insurance? It’s a fear that keeps a lot of people from finding out.

In Canada, the Genetic Non-Discrimination Act has been law since 2017, and the Supreme Court of Canada upheld it in 2020. Insurers and employers can’t require you to take a genetic test, or to share results you already have, as a condition of coverage or a job. I’m not a lawyer, and the rules are different outside Canada, so ask your genetic counsellor how this applies to you. But it’s a real protection, and it exists so that fear doesn’t stop people from knowing.

If a change is found

Knowing that you have a genetic predisposition to cancer doesn’t change your genes. It does, however, change your options.

In Ontario, people ages 30 to 69 who carry a change like BRCA1, BRCA2, PALB2 or TP53 can be referred to the High Risk Ontario Breast Screening Program, which screens once a year with a mammogram and a breast MRI. Some close relatives of carriers who have had genetic counselling can be referred too. For men, a known variant can mean earlier and closer prostate screening. Other risk-reducing options exist, and every one of them is a decision to make with your care team, at your own pace.

For my daughter, that could mean screening that starts years earlier than it did for me. For my son, it could mean a doctor who knows to ask the questions mine never did.

How to prepare for genetic counselling

Start with a family tree. Mine fits on one page. For each relative, note:

  • How they’re related to you, and which side of the family they’re on
  • What kind of cancer they had, and roughly how old they were when diagnosed
  • Whether they’ve been tested, and the result if you know it

Include everyone, even the cancers that don’t seem related. Liver and brain count. Map maternal and paternal lines.

If a relative has been tested, ask for a copy of the report. It can be the starting point for your own assessment.

Then take it to your oncologist or family doctor and ask:

  1. Does my family history, on both sides, qualify me for genetic counselling?
  2. Can we add the men’s cancers to my family history?
  3. A relative has been tested. Can I be tested for the same change?
  4. Which genes are on the panel?
  5. If I carry something, what does it mean for my sons and my daughters?
  6. If my result is negative, what does that tell my family, and what doesn’t it?

If you’d like a sounding board first, AskEllyn can help you prepare for appointments and work out what to ask.

Questions people ask about prostate and breast cancer

Can breast cancer risk come from your father’s side?

Yes. The genes linked to breast cancer can be inherited from either parent. Your father’s, grandfather’s and uncles’ cancers belong in your family history.

Is prostate cancer linked to breast cancer?

Prostate and breast cancer cluster in some families, and several genes, including BRCA1, BRCA2, ATM and CHEK2, are tied to both. A family pattern is a reason to ask questions. It doesn’t predict that you’ll get cancer.

How do I get genetic testing?

Start with your family doctor or oncologist. If your personal or family history suggests it, they can refer you for a hereditary cancer genetic assessment. Bring your family tree and any relatives’ test results.

Will a genetic test affect my insurance?

In Canada, the Genetic Non-Discrimination Act, upheld by the Supreme Court of Canada in 2020, means insurers can’t require you to take a genetic test or disclose results as a condition of coverage. The US has a more nuanced approach. The federal Genetic Information Nondiscrimination Act (GINA, 2008) bars health insurers and employers from using genetic information. Genetic information also can’t be treated as a pre-existing condition. But GINA doesn’t apply to employers with fewer than 15 employees. A genetic counsellor can explain how it applies to your situation.

Where I am now with genetic testing

I don’t have results. I don’t even have an appointment yet. I have a one-page family tree, a list of questions, a request into my GP oncologist and a cousin I need to call.

I’ll keep you posted on how it goes.

If you’re building your own list of questions at 2 a.m., AskEllyn is up too. And if you want the whole story of how I got here, it’s in Flat Please, Hold the Shame. Just skip the part where I said I had no family history.

— Ellyn

Sources

Ellyn Winters Robinson

Ellyn Winters-Robinson is a breast cancer survivor, entrepreneur, author, in-demand speaker, women’s health advocate, professional communicator and a globally recognized health rebel. Ellyn's best-selling book "Flat Please Hold the Shame," is a girlfriend’s companion guide for those on the breast cancer journey. She is also the co-creator of AskEllyn.ai, the world’s first conversational AI companion for those on the breast cancer journey. With Dense Breasts Canada and award-winning photographer Hilary Gauld, Ellyn also co-produced I WANT YOU TO KNOW, a celebrated photo essay showing the diverse faces and stories of 31 individuals on the breast cancer journey. Ellyn’s story and AskEllyn.ai have been featured in People Magazine, Chatelaine Magazine, the Globe and Mail, CTV National News and Your Morning, and Fast Company.

You may also like

This error message is only visible to WordPress admins

Error: No feed with the ID 9 found.

Please go to the Instagram Feed settings page to create a feed.